A year after moving to Tampa, my husband and I celebrated our first wedding anniversary at Oystercatchers overlooking Tampa Bay. When we arrived for our reservation, a typical Florida summer deluge had us running from the car to find refuge in the warm and inviting space. Inside, we sat by the windows overlooking the water, keeping an eye out for dolphins while dining on fresh seafood. It was a meal to remember in our early days as a young, married couple.
Decades later one, of our neighbors fondly shared how he would join his friends for hours of eating and drinking at Oystercatchers' famed Sunday brunch, complete with bottomless mimosas and mounds of crab legs and shrimp.
My husband and I recently returned to Oystercatchers more than 20 years after our first anniversary dinner to check out the new iteration of the restaurant, including fresh interiors and a new dock to which diners can arrive by boat.
The centerpiece, though, is the reimagined menu that honors the restaurant's legacy of fresh seafood and coastal-inspired cuisine, while at the same time looking ahead to the future. The new look, feel, and flavors are all in celebration of Oystercatchers' 40th anniversary this month.
Credit: Melissa Santell
40 Years and a Fresh Start
Leading the charge is chef de cuisine Shelby Farrell, who came to Oystercatchers a year and a half ago by way of Richard Blais' Michelin-recommended Four Flamingos in Orlando. Raised on Florida's Emerald Coast, Farrell's culinary career has been inspired not only by the fresh seafood she enjoyed during her childhood, but but also by learning to cook old-world Italian dishes with her nonna and during her first kitchen job at her uncle's restaurant on the Mississippi coast.
"I grew up on the Florida Panhandle, and my family's from just outside Biloxi, Mississippi, so Southern coastal seafood has always been my specialty; that's what brought me here [to Oystercatchers]," she says. "I was in Orlando for many years running a Southern, coastal-inspired seafood restaurant there, and when I heard that Oystercatchers was looking for a new chef to oversee and overhaul the restaurant and to lean more into that style, it was the perfect fit for me."
"The thing is with the restaurant, we're sitting right on Tampa Bay, we're looking out onto the Gulf, and that in itself is inspirational," she adds. "I get to look at the water, where such a large portion of our seafood comes from, from my kitchen every single day. It is awesome."
It's more than the views for Farrell, though.
"There's a level of connectedness with the product we serve that I've never really experienced in a restaurant before," she says. "We really lean into products that we can get from our local waters and are in the process of teaming up with a new oyster [company] that is operating out of Tampa Bay. We're excited to go that hyperlocal with our oysters."
Credit: Melissa Santell
Florida Flavors and More
Beyond seafood, Farrell seeks out local purveyors for the restaurant's fruits and vegetables, too, for dishes like the Hearts of Palm Ceviche, a vegan dish that she says, as a former vegetarian herself, was the first she created for the new menu.
"We're very lucky in the state of Florida to be one of the few places where you can get fresh hearts of palm. Generally, outside of Florida, Costa Rica, and Hawaii, you can't find them because they have such a short shelf life," she says. "We have access to fresh hearts of palm coming from Homestead. It is such a uniquely available product that I wanted to really showcase it."
"I love a good traditional ceviche, and that dish is rooted in a traditional Peruvian-style leche de tigre ceviche, but is completely vegan," she adds. "It's a fun way to spin it and make it unique to us."
Farrell's unique perspective flows throughout Oystercatchers' new menu, from oysters served with a seasonal blackberry mignonette; Gulf Gold Shrimp Cocktail served with Alabama white sauce; the fresh catch of the day served with a flight of tempting sides; and Blackened Prawn Étouffée, one of her favorite dishes on the new menu.
Credit: Melissa Santell
"New Orleans cuisine is something I'm very influenced by," she says. "We make a very traditional étouffée sauce, but then we reduce it down and blend it smooth into more of a velouté for a more refined version. And we serve it with pimento rice grits that we get from Congaree and Penn, a rice and grain farm in Jacksonville."
Rounding out the menu are tantalizing desserts, including a Coconut Cream Pie made with the same recipe Farrell and her brother use for their mother's birthday every year.
Diners are also invited to bring in their own fresh catch to be prepared for lunch or dinner via Oystercatcher's Catch and Cook program. Fish is grilled, blackened, or fried, and served with a flight of house sauces and sides.
"I don't think there are very many restaurants in town that offer that feature, especially when you're quite literally stepping off the boat and handing [the fish] to the kitchen," says Farrell.
To the Next 40 Years
As far as Oystercatchers' iconic Sunday Brunch, well, that's been reimagined, too, featuring a raw bar; salad bar; signature omelets like one with lobster tail and lump crab; traditional dishes; fresh pastries; and more.
Credit: Melissa Santell
After a year and a half creating and fine-tuning Oystercatchers' reimagined menu for its 40th anniversary, Farrell and her team are far from resting on their laurels. Rather, she says that menu development never ends.
"We do daily specials, and that is 95% to test and refine future menu items," she says. "We put a lot of thought and heart into our specials because quite a few of them end up on the menu."
One dish she's refining at the moment is her take on a Thai green curry. She's taking a blend of aromatics like lemongrass, lime, ginger, peppers, and herbs, grinding it into a paste and cooking it with coconut milk.
"It's so fresh and so light, and it goes so well with seafood," Farrell says. "I've been working on a dish that features a house-made green curry with Florida spiny lobster tail."
It's Farrell's and her team's creativity, ingenuity, and fresh perspective that will lead Oystercatchers into the future. I, for one, cannot wait to see what's next.
Read the original article on Southern Living