I remember the first time my mom made mincemeat pie. One day, when I was about 8 years old, I wandered into our cozy eat-in kitchen, which was completely enveloped in avocado green—from the refrigerator to the cabinet stain to the linoleum. I had followed the sweet, spicy, citrusy scents of apples, raisins, brown sugar, lemon zest, cinnamon, and nutmeg across the house and knew she must be baking something good.
Y'all Don't Want To Miss This
Join Southern Living Insiders today to unlock 60 years of vintage recipes, exclusive deals, a special edition of our best-selling cookbook, and a weekly newsletter just for members. JOIN TODAY
"Mama, what are you making?" I asked.
"Mincemeat pie!" she replied.
"Mince what?" I asked, completely repulsed and somewhat alarmed.
"Mincemeat. You mean you don't know what mincemeat is?" she said, looking at me like I'd fallen out of the family tree. "We've had it at Thanksgiving forever. This was my Mama's recipe."
Suddenly, it rang a bell. I remembered seeing a brown pie on the sideboard among all the other treats some years at Thanksgiving and Christmas. But it was dark and lumpy—and I suspected it might contain walnuts, which I despised—so I had always steered clear of it and grabbed a cookie instead. Now, my distrust for this pie was only growing. "Why would anyone ruin a dessert with meat?" I asked, with mounting concern.
"It doesn't have meat in the filling, just raisins and apples and lots of spices," she answered.
The Taste Test
Somewhat reassured but still a little skeptical, I later mustered up the courage to try a bite after Thanksgiving dinner. If our family had been eating it forever, it must not be too terrible, right?
To my relief, it was surprisingly delicious. The spices (like nutmeg, cinnamon, and cloves) combined with chopped apples, raisins, and lemon and orange zests to taste like a warm hug. My mother put a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream on top, and I stirred it together so the potent ribbons of spicy pie were mellowed out a bit by the rich ice cream. She told me she'd made the dessert because it reminded her of her own mother.
A Storied Past
Credit: Photo © StockXpert
I've since learned that mincemeat comes by its name honestly. It dates back hundreds of years to the Old World and was a way to preserve chopped meats like beef, mutton, game birds, or venison by combining them with available spices, sugars, and/or alcohol. Because the spices often had to be imported to Europe, the dish was more costly and became associated with holidays and other celebrations. Modern versions rarely include meat, but if you grab a store-bought jar of mincemeat, check the brand's ingredients list if it's important to you to avoid that.
Straight From Our Recipe Vault
Credit: Robby Lozano; Food Stylist: Margaret Dickey; Prop Stylist: Maddie Clark
This recipe for Cranberry Mincemeat Pie calls for prepared mincemeat, whole cranberry sauce, pecans, and brandy in a parbaked pastry shell and is available by joining Southern Living Insiders. The pie first appeared in our November 1976 issue and was submitted by Miss Mavis Womack of Ackerman, Mississippi. I don't know if Miss Womack ever crossed paths with my Mississippi-born grandmother, but I'm pretty sure they would have really enjoyed swapping tips for making the best mincemeat pie.
Read the original article on Southern Living