Politics

Britain needs to plan for the future, not vibe its way back to the EU past

Britain needs to plan for the future, not vibe its way back to the EU past
Image: yahoo.com

Why does it feel as if so many in politics can only look backwards?

Some want to take Britain back to the 1950s; the Prime Minister wants to take us back to the 1990s. He talks of hope but forgets that the anthem of those days, "Things Can Only Get Better", was about the future. Nothing gets better by pretending we can turn back time.

Sadly, that is what Andy Burnham tried on Friday. Standing in Brussels, he announced he'd done a deal with the EU. So where is it? All we have is a statement welcoming the end of negotiations on food and farming, on carbon markets and on a youth scheme, and a set of dates described as aims. That's raised a lot of questions, but has given no answers.

We're told Britain will follow EU food and farming laws when they change after March 2028, but not which laws it will follow, what it means for existing treaties with Australia and India, who settles a dispute, or what say Parliament will have.

We are told that questions about what European students will pay at British universities – a bill the Russell Group puts at £570m a year – will be answered within six months, but not the implication for universities, even though vice-chancellors have said it could bankrupt them. We're even told by his ministers that rejoining is on the table, but not the timetable or the cost – in time and distraction – that this would place on all of us.

Once again, Our Andy seems to think that negotiating with Brussels is like haggling with the bus companies for £2 fares. But as any farmer will tell you, fine words butter no parsnips, and when you have to decide what to plant, when, and where, it's the rules that matter, and who makes them.

The Brexit debates left Parliament without the bandwidth to address anything that actually mattered to the voters - PA/UK Parliament/Mark Duffy

What about a chemical plant or a factory? Who would build one in Britain if they're not sure what the rules will be and who will set them? No one. What Burnham is promising isn't some return to the days of D:Ream and Britpop, but another decade of division, confusion, delay, cost and distraction. This is government by vibes, and nobody's future is built on vapours.

Only someone who missed the meaningful votes, midnight divisions and years when compromise meant a barely holding truce between different factions in one party, could talk of going back there. Parliament was frozen and the biggest cause of our problems today is that, for 10 years, we didn't have the bandwidth to address anything that actually mattered to the people who sent us there. Schools, taxes, infrastructure, everything had to wait. Now Andy wants us to wait again.

Even the companies that were against leaving don't want to go through this again. Chemical firms that spent some £500m registering their products under the EU's rules, then even more to do it again under ours. Is it any surprise they don't want to pay a third time for the same outcome?

The City lost its passport and rebuilt its business without one. Now it needs to focus on generating the capital to fund our future. It does not need to be told that the Government will pass on new rules to constrain it without even the ability to change them. It understands what the Prime Minister does not. Leaving did not solve all our problems and rejoining won't fix them now.

Britain can't be half-in, taking rules we don't write. We're not Norway. Oslo's wealth lies under the North Sea and no regulation written in Brussels can take it. Ours lies in finance, services, research, and farming, in everything that rules can shape and move.

And Europe's leaders have a duty to pass rules that favour their own citizens, not ours. That's their responsibility to their own people. We need our leaders to recognise that their responsibility is the same – and that means we can never be bound by the rules written to help others.
This isn't the EU of 2016
After a decade, you'd have thought ministers would have learned that you can't talk your way round Brussels, or pretend that their software can be reprogrammed with idiosyncrasies. It can't. It won't. You can't vibe-code Brussels, it's stone-coded. Its rules are chiselled into rock line by line in careful deals between member states. Outsiders don't get to scratch them out.

That's their strength and their weakness. It makes them tough negotiators and tougher still to change.

They're regulated by the past, but the future is here. Artificial intelligence is rewriting every industry, and Chinese factories are stealing them. Cars, batteries, and steel won't be made in Europe if they can't shift their data rules, but Germany and Greece can't agree, and that means OpenAI and others won't even think about building in the EU.

Britain shouldn't reject tech but embrace it. We're growing faster than our European equivalents and will stay ahead because we're allowing the innovation and ideas, capital and creativity, to stay one step ahead of the demographics and regulations that Europe's treaties embed.

More than that, these talks are pointless. This isn't the EU of 2016, and this time next year it will include voices many wish silent. Marine Le Pen is leading the polls five months before France votes, and the AfD in Germany is ensuring no party will be dominant in the continent's largest economy. Their attention will be on managing themselves, leaving no bandwidth or interest in taking Britain back. We need to plan for the future, not try to vibe our way back to the past.

That doesn't mean we should stand alone. We already work with our neighbours in the Joint Expeditionary Force – 10 Nato nations that guard the Baltic and the High North – and we could do more.

As Russia's war in Ukraine continues, and its threats to others grow, we need to think of the alliance we need for the next decade, not the last one.

Just think what we could do if we actually thought of the future, then things really would get better.

Tom Tugendhat is the shadow foreign secretary

Try full access to The Telegraph free today. Unlock their award-winning website and essential news app, plus useful tools and expert guides for your money, health and holidays.

Source: yahoo.com