What do blue jeans, Costco hot dogs, and classic American cocktails have in common? They've all stood the test of time. Some cocktails had their moment in the spotlight before disappearing from bar menus completely, while others seem to stick around. So, what separates a passing trend from a true American classic? It's a pretty simple recipe: a cocktail that's easy to drink, memorable enough to have a reputation, and good enough to keep people ordering it week after week.
While America didn't invent mixed drinks, it did play a role in officially defining them. The first time the word cocktail was given a description was over 200 years ago, published in response to a reader's question in a New York newspaper in 1806. The newspaper's editor characterized the "cocktail" as similar to the old fashioned, made of spirits, water, sugar, and bitters.
After spending some time behind the bar, I learned that people can be surprisingly loyal to their cocktails. Some drinks have a hometown following, like the Sazerac from New Orleans, while others are saved for special occasions, like a birthday or anniversary. And then there are the regulars fiercely committed to "their" drink. I leaned on my bartending observations, while also accounting for national popularity, when ranking these timeless American cocktails.
Read more: Regional Sandwiches Every Food Lover Should Try Once
14. Harvey Wallbanger
Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock
If you were of drinking age in the 1970s, you might remember the Harvey Wallbanger having its moment; the drink was everywhere, from discos to dinner parties. The cocktail was first created in the late '50s by Donato "Duke" Antone, the bartender of the eponymous Duke's Black Watch Bar on Sunset Boulevard in Los Angeles. The cocktail's namesake? Tom Harvey, a local surfer who frequented Duke's and often ordered orange juice, vodka, and Galliano as a mixed drink. As the story goes, one day Tom lost a surfing competition, ordered and threw back his preferred drink, and banged his head against the wall in despair.
A Harvey Wallbanger is essentially a Screwdriver with a Galliano floater; Galliano, an Italian liqueur, adds notes of vanilla and anise. When popularity surged for the Harvey Wallbanger in the 1970s, marketing was mostly to thank. In 1969, a Galliano importer launched an advertising campaign — featuring a cartoon surfer mascot named Harvey — that helped to turn the drink into a household name. The only reason this refreshing cocktail ranks at the bottom is because younger drinkers almost never order it. Maybe it's time for a new ad campaign?
13. Mint julep
Juan Jose Napuri/Getty Images
The mint julep has deep historical roots in the American South, going as far back as the 18th century. Long before it became the signature drink of the Kentucky Derby, Virginians sipped juleps made with rum as a morning pick-me-up type of drink. Nowadays, an estimated 125,000 mint juleps, requiring over 10,000 bottles of Kentucky bourbon, are poured for fans over the Kentucky Derby weekend.
I've seen customer interest in mint juleps spike in the weeks around the Derby in late spring. A Southern bar or a bar in a city with a Derby fan base is likely to be stocked with all the necessary ingredients. A traditional mint julep is made with Kentucky bourbon, fresh mint (muddled and used as a garnish), and simple syrup poured over crushed ice. It's served in a silver or pewter cup, adding another signature touch to the drink. Just note that you might not have much luck ordering the cocktail in the winter months when mint may be out of season. For that reason, it stays close to the bottom of the list, while more versatile beverages outrank it.
12. Lynchburg Lemonade
Nadir Keklik/Shutterstock
In 1980, Tony Mason, a restaurant owner in Huntsville, Alabama, first mixed up this now-iconic Southern cocktail. The Lynchburg Lemonade combines Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey, triple sec, lemon juice, simple syrup, and lemon-lime soda, typically served in a highball glass. Though the conception of the drink took place in Alabama, the controversy surrounding the cocktail happened in its neighboring state. Just shy of a decade later, in 1987, Mason sued the Jack Daniel's distillery for stealing his cocktail and advertising it in a national campaign. The theft took place after Mason made the mistake of sharing the cocktail recipe with a Jack Daniel's rep. Though Mason took the whiskey giant to court, he didn't win his claim.
Despite the legal battle, the cocktail became closely associated with the Jack Daniel's brand and remains a go-to Southern drink. I think its appeal comes down to its inviting flavor. Who doesn't love a cold glass of lemonade on a hot day? In a Lynchburg Lemonade, the whiskey is balanced by citrus and sweetness, making it more enticing to people who aren't necessarily whiskey fans but are looking for an approachable drink.
11. Sazerac
Bhofack2/Getty Images
There's nothing more exciting than bellying up to a bar in New Orleans and ordering the city's official cocktail. While Sazerac and New Orleans go hand in hand, you may have a harder time ordering the drink at your average bar in another state. Categorized as more of a specialty cocktail, I've found that not all bartenders outside of New Orleans are willing or interested in making a Sazerac.
The Sazerac was believed to have been invented in the 1800s at an apothecary shop in the French Quarter — specifically, on Royal Street. What elevates the drink to iconic status is its ritualistic preparation. This may also be the reason that some bartenders outside of The Big Easy don't bother with it. To make a classic Sazerac, just chill two rocks glasses and coat one with absinthe, then strain in a stirred mix of rye whiskey, sugar, and Peychaud's bitters and garnish with a twist. It's a strong drink with a loyal following, but the Sazerac isn't for everyone. There are some who don't care for the flavors of spice and anise from the rye whiskey and absinthe, respectively.
10. Sidecar
Viennetta/Getty Images
The Sidecar is one of those classic cocktails that sounds a little more intimidating than it actually is. Made with cognac, orange liqueur, and fresh lemon juice, it's essentially a citrus-infused brandy sour. Some variations also include a sugared rim, which helps to balance out the tartness in the drink. The Sidecar, minus a few ingredients, is an offshoot of the Brandy Crusta, believed to be first mixed in New Orleans in the 19th century.
Even with such a long history, the Sidecar isn't always the first drink that comes to mind when ordering at a bar. It's recognizable among cocktail lovers but has nowhere near the notoriety of, say, a martini. Though it's lower on the scale of universal popularity, which affects its ranking here, it almost never gets sent back. Typically, when someone orders a Sidecar, they know exactly what they want to drink. A Sidecar is worth ordering if you enjoy sours (whiskey, amaretto) and want to try a new spin on familiar flavors.
9. Moscow mule
VDB Photos/Shutterstock
Although its name suggests Russian origins, the Moscow mule is very much an American drink. It played a part in introducing vodka to Americans at a time when the spirit wasn't as in demand as gin or whiskey. According to one popular account: In 1941, three people in Los Angeles came together with products they needed to sell. Sophie Berezinski was an immigrant with a surplus of copper cups, Jack Morgan owned a pub and had excess ginger beer, and John Martin, a spirits exec, was looking to promote Smirnoff vodka in an unwelcoming market. Their collab would ultimately birth the Moscow mule, made with vodka, ginger beer, and fresh lime juice and served in a signature copper mug.
From a bartender's perspective, the Moscow mule checks several important boxes. The ingredients are widely available, the recipe is easy to remember, and the combination of ginger and lime appeals to a broad range of tastes. I've also seen its popularity extend beyond the bar top, with canned and pre-mixed versions becoming common. And it's almost impossible to ruin, so you can safely order it anywhere from a dive bar to a cocktail lounge.
8. Manhattan
Bhofack2/Getty Images
The Manhattan is known for being one of the first modern cocktails, and yet, over 30 percent of people say they still haven't tried the drink. It's made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters, with origins tracing back to the 1860s in New York City. While its creation is often incorrectly credited to Winston Churchill's mother, Lady Churchill, historians say the drink was more likely born in New York bars as bartenders began using sweet vermouth.
Today, it's a staple at cocktail bars and a familiar name to most people, though casual drinkers don't usually gravitate toward its whiskey-forward flavor. Sweet vermouth also gives it a complexity that you won't find in smoother, vodka-based drinks. Still, I believe the Manhattan deserves its middle-of-the-pack spot among the classics. It's a great choice for anyone who enjoys whiskey and wants something a little more interesting than a standard mixed drink. You also won't have a hard time finding it at any bar that stocks basic cocktail ingredients.
7. Whiskey sour
Vitalii Voznyi/Shutterstock
The whiskey sour is one of those cocktails that manages to appeal to both traditionalists as well as anyone wanting a refreshing drink. The classic recipe is straightforward, combining whiskey, lemon juice, and simple syrup. Sour drinks were being enjoyed as far back as the 1600s, though it wasn't until 1862 that a recipe for a whiskey sour was found in print. Since then, countless variations of the whiskey sour have emerged, including the Boston sour, which typically adds egg white, and the New York sour, which floats dry red wine. (Despite the name, the New York sour actually may have first been created in Chicago in the 1880s.)
I think the whiskey sour remains timeless, and (nearly) the best American cocktail, because it's so adaptable. Drinkers can enjoy it with bourbon or rye, adjust the sweetness, or opt for a version with wine or egg white. It's also relatively easy to find at most bars, even those without extensive cocktail menus. Nearly 200 years later, the whiskey sour is still making a strong case for keeping things simple.
6. Bloody mary
Bhofack2/Getty Images
A favorite brunch beverage, Americans have been sipping on bloody marys for nearly a hundred years. For those who prefer savory over sweet, the bloody (with all of its many garnishes) has developed a cult following. First introduced in the 1920s in Paris and perfected in the U.S. soon after, the bloody mary combines vodka with tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce, horseradish, hot sauce, lemon, and seasonings. It's an acquired taste for some, though its commonness among bar culture places it firmly among the top bevvies.
While its origins are often disputed, bartender Fernand Petiot was believed to have developed the modern version of the bloody mary while working at New York's St. Regis Hotel in the 1930s. For this reason, we claim it as an American cocktail, and its evolution supports this. Over time, garnishes have become increasingly over-the-top, moving beyond the traditional stalk of celery. Some viral spots have gone so far as to serve their bloodys with a whole lobster or Cornish game hen. The bloody mary has also seen success in the ready-to-drink market. Canned versions are now available for bloody lovers who want a savory cocktail poolside.
5. Long Island iced tea
Bhofack2/Getty Images
Love it or hate it, the Long Island iced tea achieved iconic American cocktail status by the sheer force of its popularity. The most widely accepted origin story for this very strong drink credits bartender Robert "Rosebud" Butt for first mixing it up in a Long Island cocktail contest in 1972. But Kingsport, Tennessee, has its own claim to the Long Island's invention: a Prohibition-era version of the drink reportedly created by Charlie Bishop in the 1920s using five liquors, with a splash of maple syrup and whiskey instead of triple sec.
The demand for a Long Island iced tea, or just a "Long Island" as it's often called, depends entirely on the crowd. I've seen Long Island imbibers tend to skew younger and often want more bang for their buck when celebrating a big event; think a 21st birthday or bachelor party. Stiff as this drink is, I still score it high on taste and likeability. The citrus and cola combo masks the booze so well that it just about, nearly, almost tastes like sweet iced tea.
4. Mai tai
lexandrumoldovanu/Shutterstock
Invented in 1944 by Victor "Trader Vic" Bergeron at his Oakland restaurant, the mai tai is a snapshot of mid-century American Tiki culture. As Bergeron explained it, he put together the cocktail to showcase a 17-year-old rum and served it to some of his friends from Tahiti. One friend reportedly exclaimed, "Maita'i roa ae," loosely translating to "out of this world" or "the best." And the name stuck.
The mai tai has been a crowd-pleaser for generations because of its tart and fruity tropical taste. Just mix up rum, lime juice, orange curaçao, orgeat, and a little simple syrup for a highly drinkable blend of citrus, almond, and rum flavors. While some resort bars have been accused of ruining the cocktail by mixing it with cheap fruit punch, you'll know a well-made mai tai as soon as you sip it. An ideal outcome is less of a sugary beach drink and more of a carefully balanced rum cocktail.
3. Cosmopolitan
Fabian Montano/Getty Images
The Cosmopolitan martini can be credited to two bartenders, Neal Murray and Cheryl Cook, who created the same drink with the same name in two different decades and cities. By the time the '90s rolled around, it quickly became a cultural touchstone thanks to it being Carrie Bradshaw's default drink. A classic Cosmo combines citrus vodka, Cointreau or another orange liqueur, cranberry juice, and fresh lime juice and is garnished with an orange peel and served in a martini glass. I see the Cosmo as a triple threat, scoring near-perfect marks for popularity, accessibility, and taste.
The Cosmo's biggest selling point? It's one of those cocktails that tastes like a treat without requiring a special occasion. While the Cosmo may not be as big as it was in the '90s — though it's poised for making a comeback — you can still order it at virtually any bar in North America. Today's version of the pink drink is often made with a few upgrades. Swapping out the cranberry for pomegranate juice is one way to elevate its flavors.
2. Old fashioned
etorres/Shutterstock
The old fashioned has been around a while, as the name suggests. Combining whiskey, sugar, bitters, and a little water, this simple (and potent) drink puts the spirit front and center. The name came about as cocktail culture shifted. By the late 19th century, drinkers had begun ordering cocktails the "old-fashioned" way, meaning a straightforward whiskey drink with minimal embellishments compared to more elaborate cocktails that were becoming popular.
The old fashioned ranks high on my list because it's well-known, easy to order, and even easier to drink. These days, the old fashioned is commonly made with bourbon or rye whiskey, though variations using different liquors and flavors can be found almost anywhere. (Try rum or Port wine.) Some bartenders add a cherry or orange slice, while others, like myself, prefer a more traditional orange peel garnish. And because of Mad Men, the old fashioned has become synonymous with sophistication, making it a natural choice for a "night out" drink.
1. Martini
Maximfesenko/Getty Images
Gin or vodka? Shaken or stirred? Dry or dirty? With or without a twist? The attraction to what I consider to be the most well-known cocktail comes down to simplicity paired with the element of choice. You can customize your martini right out of the gate, and if you know the lingo, you sound even cooler when ordering it. If you don't, you can ask your friendly bartender to explain or just stick with what works: A dry gin martini is a great starting point.
The martini's origins date back to the 1880s, with one popular, though disputed, story crediting a bartender in Martinez, California. According to the story, the bartender mixed up a "Martinez Special" for a miner during the Gold Rush, originally said to more closely resemble a Manhattan. Over the decades, the drink evolved to become the clear blend of gin or vodka and dry vermouth we know today. With more than 40 percent of people saying they love a martini, and nearly 20 percent ordering one on their most recent bar visit, I consider it the most beloved, and iconic, American cocktail.
Methodology
Claudio Dominic T.D/Shutterstock
I ranked these iconic American cocktails based on my years of experience working as a bartender. Not only have I mixed and tried each one myself countless times, I've also ordered them. My criteria for ranking was based on several key factors: popularity, or how well-known a drink is and how often it was ordered among customers; availability, or how easily you could walk into a bar and order it; and taste/likeability, or how often it was sent back. I also reviewed several outside surveys to get a clearer view of popularity and preference.
Since "iconicness" factored heavily into the rankings, I made sure to consider history, confirming that each cocktail was American-made and had multiple decades of being consumed. Many of these timeless cocktails were created more than a hundred years ago. Several fell into the category of modern-day classics, with the "youngest" on the list dating back no further than the 1980s.
Want more food knowledge? Sign up to our free newsletter where we're helping thousands of foodies, like you, become culinary masters, one email at a time. You can also add us as a preferred search source or follow us on Google.
Read the original article on Tasting Table.